Built Heritage Sub-Committee

Votes Send Comments

Item/File Ext.
minutes 30 - thursday, 10 may 2018
English Minutes 30
French Minutes 30
application to alter 255 mackay street, a property located in new edinburgh heritage conservation district, designated under part v of the ontario heritage act
Report – 255 MacKay St
Possibly related devapp: D02-02-18-0007
application for demolition and new construction at 90 crichton street, a property located in new edinburgh heritage conservation district, designated under part v of the ontario heritage act
Report - 90 Crichton Street
application for demolition and new construction at 443 and 447 kent street, and alteration at 423-425 mcleod street, properties located in the centretown heritage conservation district, designated under part v of the ontario heritage act
Report – 443 and 447 Kent St and 423-425 McLeod St
Document 11 – Cultural Heritage Impact Statement
Revised supporting documents 6, 7 and 8
Possibly related devapp: D07-12-17-0173
Possibly related devapp: D02-02-17-0126
application to alter the ch'teau laurier hotel, 1 rideau street, a property designated under part iv of the ontario heritage act
Report - Chateau Laurier
Document 15 - CHIS Addendum - 9 May 2018
Document 16 - Memo – Revised CHIS Addendum 29 May 2018
Document 21 - UDRP Recommendations
Document 22 - UDRP Subcommittee Recommendations
Document 23 - UDRP Discussion with Staff
Document 31 - Heritage Working Group - Meeting 1
Document 32 - Heritage Working Group - Meeting 2
Document 33 - Heritage Working Group - Meeting 3
Document 34 - Parks Canada Letter
Document 35 - Heritage Ottawa Letter
Possibly related devapp: D02-02-13-0129
Possibly related devapp: D07-12-16-0193
Possibly related devapp: D07-12-17-0166
technical circulations
zoning by-law amendment proposal - 110 york street and 137 george street
Summary - Zoning Proposal - 110 York St and 137 George St (BIL)
Possibly related devapp: D07-12-12-0199
Possibly related devapp: D02-02-12-0126
Possibly related devapp: D02-02-18-0038
Possibly related devapp: D07-12-12-0199
Possibly related devapp: D02-02-12-0126
Possibly related devapp: D02-02-16-0090
Possibly related devapp: D02-02-18-0038
zoning by-law amendment and subdivision proposal - 21 withrow avenue
Summary - Zoning and Subdivision Proposal – 21 Withrow Avenue (BIL)
Possibly related devapp: D07-16-17-0027
Possibly related devapp: D02-02-17-0104
Possibly related devapp: D08-02-17/A-00345
Possibly related devapp: D08-01-17/B-00427

Votes

ITEM: Minutes 30 - Thursday, 10 May 2018

Motion Yes No Absent/Recused
Motion To:
pop-out
B. Padolsky
T. Nussbaum
S. Moffatt (a)
L. A. (Sandy) Smallwood (a)
M. Wilkinson (a)
C. Quinn (a)
C. McKenney (a)

ITEM: APPLICATION TO ALTER 255 MACKAY STREET, A PROPERTY LOCATED IN NEW EDINBURGH HERITAGE CONSERVATION DISTRICT, DESIGNATED UNDER PART V OF THE ONTARIO HERITAGE ACT

Motion Yes No Absent/Recused
Motion To: Que le Sous-comité du patrimoine bâti recommande au Comité de l’urbanisme de recommander à son tour au Conseil : 1. d’approuver la demande de modification du bâtiment situé au 255, rue MacKay, conformément aux plans présentés par Robertson Martin architectes et reçus le 8 juin 2018; 2. d’approuver la demande de démolition du garage existant et de construction d’un nouveau garage dans l’allée Avon, conformément aux plans présentés par Robertson Martin architectes et reçus le 8 juin 2018; 3. d'approuver le plan de l'aménagement paysager présenté par Robertson Martin architectes et reçus le 8 juin 2018; 4. de déléguer au directeur général de Planification, Infrastructure et Développement économique le pouvoir d’apporter des changements mineurs de conception; 5. de délivrer le permis en matière de patrimoine dont la date d’expiration est fixée à deux ans après la date d’émission; 6. de renoncer à la signification de l’avis prév
pop-out
S. Moffatt
B. Padolsky
L. A. (Sandy) Smallwood
M. Wilkinson
C. Quinn
C. McKenney
T. Nussbaum

ITEM: APPLICATION FOR DEMOLITION AND NEW CONSTRUCTION AT 90 CRICHTON STREET, A PROPERTY LOCATED IN NEW EDINBURGH HERITAGE CONSERVATION DISTRICT, DESIGNATED UNDER PART V OF THE ONTARIO HERITAGE ACT

Motion Yes No Absent/Recused
Motion To: Que le Sous-comité du patrimoine bâti recommande au Comité de l’urbanisme de recommander à son tour au Conseil : 1. D’approuver la demande de démolition du bâtiment et du garage situés au 90, rue Crichton, conformément aux plans de Dustin Design Drafting, reçus le 2 mai 2018; 2. D’approuver la demande de construction au 90, rue Crichton, conformément aux plans de Dustin Design Drafting, reçus le 2 mai 2018; 3. D’approuver le plan d’aménagement paysager visant le 90, rue Crichton, conformément aux plans de Dustin Design Drafting, reçus le 2 mai 2018; 4. De déléguer au directeur général de Planification, Infrastructure et Développement économique le pouvoir d’apporter des changements mineurs de conception; 5. De délivrer le permis en matière de patrimoine dont la date d’expiration est fixée à deux ans après la date d’émission. (Nota : Le délai réglementaire de 90 jours d’examen de cette demande, exigé en vertu de la Loi sur le pat
pop-out
S. Moffatt
B. Padolsky
L. A. (Sandy) Smallwood
M. Wilkinson
C. Quinn
C. McKenney
T. Nussbaum

ITEM: APPLICATION FOR DEMOLITION AND NEW CONSTRUCTION AT 443 AND 447 KENT STREET, AND ALTERATION AT 423-425 MCLEOD STREET, PROPERTIES LOCATED IN THE CENTRETOWN HERITAGE CONSERVATION DISTRICT, DESIGNATED UNDER PART V OF THE ONTARIO HERITAGE ACT

Motion Yes No Absent/Recused
Motion To: WHEREAS the Applicant has submitted revised the Site Plan, Elevations and Renderings dated June 15, 2018 with respect to the 443 and 447 Kent Street, and Alteration at 423-425 McLeod Street in response to community input; THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED THAT the recommendations are amended by deleting the words “May 29, 2018” and substituting the words “June 15, 2018”; and, BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED THAT the report is amended by deleting “0.9m” and substituting “1.6m”; and BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED THAT Documents 4, 6 and 7 of the report be replaced with the attached revised Site Plan, Elevations and Renderings dated June 15, 2018.
pop-out

ITEM: APPLICATION TO ALTER THE CH'TEAU LAURIER HOTEL, 1 RIDEAU STREET, A PROPERTY DESIGNATED UNDER PART IV OF THE ONTARIO HERITAGE ACT

Motion Yes No Absent/Recused
Motion To: WHEREAS City Council adopted the Parks Canada’s document “Standards and Guidelines for the Conservation of Historic Places in Canada” in 2008; and WHEREAS Standard 11 of that document states that additions must be “physically and visually compatible with, subordinate to, and distinguishable from the historic place”; WHEREAS “compatible” is generally agreed to mean “able to exist or work together without conflict”; WHEREAS the proposed addition is not sufficiently visually compatible with the Chateau Laurier, a historic place WHEREAS additional modifications to the design of the proposed addition are necessary to ensure its visual compatibility with the existing Chateau Laurier, an iconic heritage landmark in the City of Ottawa and the National Capital; THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED that Recommendation 1 be amended to state that the application be approved on the following conditions: That staff be directed to work with the applicant to make the proposed addition
pop-out
S. Moffatt
B. Padolsky
L. A. (Sandy) Smallwood
M. Wilkinson
C. Quinn
C. McKenney
T. Nussbaum
Motion To: That the Built Heritage Sub-Committee recommend that Planning Committee recommend that Council: 1. Approve the application to alter the Château Laurier, 1 Rideau Street, a property designated under Part IV of the Ontario Heritage Act, based on plans received on May 9 and 30, 2018, on the condition that staff be directed to work with the applicant to make the proposed addition more visually compatible with the existing Chateau Laurier, prior to site plan approval, by: a. meaningfully increasing the use of Indiana limestone cladding on the building exterior to reduce its contrast and enhance its bond with the existing building; b. modifying the addition by sculpting, recessing, and breaking up the unrelieved uniformity of the north façade using elements and forms that are specifically drawn from, and relate to, the existing Chateau Laurier’s rich palette of forms; c. altering the architectural expression on the north, west and east facades to introduce fenestration pattern
pop-out
S. Moffatt
B. Padolsky
L. A. (Sandy) Smallwood
M. Wilkinson
C. Quinn
C. McKenney
T. Nussbaum

Public Comment Contact Information

Everyone is entitled to attend committee meetings and provide a verbal statement (up to 5 minutes long) before Councillors vote on each agenda item. If you are not able to attend a meeting, you can also email your comments to councillors. Either way, your statements become part of the official record - and this is the single most important step to shaping the outcome of your city.

Click this "mailto:" link, or cut-and-paste the following email addresses to send your comments:

eric.pelot@ottawa.ca, catherine.mckenney@ottawa.ca, scott.moffatt@ottawa.ca, tobi.nussbaum@ottawa.ca, marianne.wilkinson@ottawa.ca

Committee Members:
Name Last Email Phone
Catherine McKenney catherine.mckenney@ottawa.ca 613-580-2484
Scott Moffatt scott.moffatt@ottawa.ca 613-580-2491
Tobi Nussbaum tobi.nussbaum@ottawa.ca 613-580-2483
Marianne Wilkinson marianne.wilkinson@ottawa.ca 613-580-2474