Built Heritage Sub-Committee

Video Votes Send Comments

Item/File Ext.
minutes 9 - 10 december 2015
BHCminutes9 (EN).doc
BHCminutes9 (FR).doc
demolition of 171 bruy're street, a property designated under part v of the ontario heritage act and located in the lowertown west heritage conservation district, and replacement with a parkette
Report - Demolition of 171 Bruyere.docx
Document 4 - Heritage Survey and Evaluation Form.pdf
Document 5 - John G Cooke Building Condition Assessment.pdf
rockcliffe park heritage conservation district plan
Report - Rockcliffe Park Heritage Conservation District Plan.docx
Doc 1 - Draft Heritage Conservation District Plan.docx
Doc 3 - Comparison Chart.docx
designation of the flewellyn/jones house, 5897 fernbank road under part iv of the ontario heritage act
Report - Designation of the Flewellyn Jones House.docx
Staff Presentation (EN).pptx
Possibly related devapp: D08-01-16/B-00173
status update - built heritage sub-committee inquiries and motions for the period ending 31 december 2015
Report - Status Update - BHSC Inquiries and Motions
new edinburgh heritage conservation district plan
Report - New Edinburgh Heritage Conservation District Plan.docx
Document 1 - New Edinburgh HCD Plan.docx
application to alter 122 daly avenue, a property designated under part v of the ontario heritage act and located in the sandy hill west heritage conservation district
Report - Application to Alter 122 Daly.docx
Document 7 - Heritage Survey.pdf
Document 8 - CHIS.pdf
Document 9 - Addendum to CHIS.pdf
Possibly related devapp: D07-12-16-0036
application for new construction at 600 minto place, a property designated under part v of the ontario heritage act and located in the rockcliffe park heritage conservation district
Report - Application for New Construction at 600 Minto.docx
review of planning applications by the built heritage sub-committee
IPD - Review of Planning Applications.docx
adjournment

Meeting Video

City Council meetings have full video and audio. Committee meetings (including the Police Services and Library boards) are audio only, so ignore the test pattern. Those videos are still playable.

Open in Youtube.

Votes

ITEM: DEMOLITION OF 171 BRUY'RE STREET, A PROPERTY DESIGNATED UNDER PART V OF THE ONTARIO HERITAGE ACT AND LOCATED IN THE LOWERTOWN WEST HERITAGE CONSERVATION DISTRICT, AND REPLACEMENT WITH A PARKETTE

Motion Yes No Absent/Recused
Motion To: Moved by / Motion de: Vice Chair Padolsky WHEREAS this item was deferred at the Built Heritage Sub-Committee meeting of 9 November 2015 to allow the property owner, Ottawa Community Housing (OCH), an opportunity to look at viable options with Infrastructure Ontario; and, WHEREAS staff has received a letter dated 11 January 2016 from the Ottawa Community Housing Corporation agreeing to an extension of the 90-day time period prescribed by the Ontario Heritage Act until March 31, 2016 so that this matter can be considered at the February meeting of the Built Heritage Sub-Committee; and, WHEREAS the intent of the request for deferral is to allow time for OCH to obtain the information from Infrastructure Ontario (issuers of the mortgage) regarding the costs associated with removing this property from the mortgage-financing package secured by the townhouse community inclusive of the 171 Bruyere Avenue; and WHEREAS this information is required to assess the viability of severance and sale in lieu of d
pop-out
B. Padolsky
L. A. (Sandy) Smallwood
M. Wilkinson
C. Quinn
C. McKenney
T. Nussbaum
S. Moffatt (a)

ITEM: ROCKCLIFFE PARK HERITAGE CONSERVATION DISTRICT PLAN

Motion Yes No Absent/Recused
Motion To: Moved by / Motion de: Vice Chair Padolsky WHEREAS the goal of adopting a Rockcliffe Park Heritage Conservation District Plan is to provide clarity and specificity to ensure appropriate and enforceable protection for the heritage attributes of the district; and, WHEREAS community consultation and review following the release of the draft HCD plan identified opportunities to further increase clarity and consistency in the plan’s language; THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED THAT: Under Section 6.0, Statement of Cultural Heritage Value, add the following under Description of Heritage Attributes: the differing patterns in the alignment of houses relative to one another – some characterized by regularity, others by irregularity; Under Section 7.1, District Policies, replace subsection 5 with the following: Severances to existing lots shall only be permitted where the resulting lots are consistent with the general lot sizes within the associated streetscape and the applicable zoning bylaw. Under Section 7.2
pop-out
B. Padolsky
L. A. (Sandy) Smallwood
M. Wilkinson
C. Quinn
C. McKenney
T. Nussbaum
S. Moffatt (a)
Motion To:
pop-out
B. Padolsky
L. A. (Sandy) Smallwood
M. Wilkinson
C. Quinn
C. McKenney
T. Nussbaum
S. Moffatt (a)

ITEM: DESIGNATION OF THE FLEWELLYN/JONES HOUSE, 5897 FERNBANK ROAD UNDER PART IV OF THE ONTARIO HERITAGE ACT

Motion Yes No Absent/Recused
Motion To: Moved by / Motion de Councillor Wilkinson WHEREAS on December 10, 2015, report ACS2015-PAI-PGM-0156 was deferred from the Built Heritage Sub-Committee at the request of the property owner, who was concerned with the inclusion of the apple orchard as a heritage attribute in the proposed Statement of Cultural Heritage Value; and WHEREAS the apple orchard, planted by the Flewellyn family in 1889, is a feature of the cultural heritage landscape of the Flewellyn/Jones House at 5897 Fernbank Road; and WHEREAS staff have met with the current property owner and prospective purchaser to discuss the condition of the building and potential redevelopment of the site; and WHEREAS the Flewellyn/Jones house may require a new foundation to ensure structural stability; and WHEREAS there is a new land use anticipated for the Flewellyn/Jones House but no development application has been submitted to date; and WHEREAS the apple orchard should be reviewed in a more comprehensive matter, as part of the development a
pop-out
Motion To: Moved by / Motion de Councillor Wilkinson WHEREAS on December 10, 2015, report ACS2015-PAI-PGM-0156 was deferred from the Built Heritage Sub-Committee at the request of the property owner, who was concerned with the inclusion of the apple orchard as a heritage attribute in the proposed Statement of Cultural Heritage Value; and WHEREAS the apple orchard, planted by the Flewellyn family in 1889, is a feature of the cultural heritage landscape of the Flewellyn/Jones House at 5897 Fernbank Road; and WHEREAS staff have met with the current property owner and prospective purchaser to discuss the condition of the building and potential redevelopment of the site; and WHEREAS the Flewellyn/Jones house may require a new foundation to ensure structural stability; and WHEREAS there is a new land use anticipated for the Flewellyn/Jones House but no development application has been submitted to date; and WHEREAS the apple orchard should be reviewed in a more comprehensive matter, as part of the development a
pop-out
B. Padolsky
L. A. (Sandy) Smallwood
M. Wilkinson
C. Quinn
C. McKenney
T. Nussbaum
S. Moffatt (a)
Motion To:
pop-out
B. Padolsky
L. A. (Sandy) Smallwood
M. Wilkinson
C. Quinn
C. McKenney
T. Nussbaum
S. Moffatt (a)

ITEM: STATUS UPDATE - BUILT HERITAGE SUB-COMMITTEE INQUIRIES AND MOTIONS FOR THE PERIOD ENDING 31 DECEMBER 2015

Motion Yes No Absent/Recused
Motion To: That the item be Carried on consent.
pop-out
B. Padolsky
L. A. (Sandy) Smallwood
M. Wilkinson
C. Quinn
C. McKenney
T. Nussbaum
S. Moffatt (a)

ITEM: NEW EDINBURGH HERITAGE CONSERVATION DISTRICT PLAN

Motion Yes No Absent/Recused
Motion To: WHEREAS the goal of adopting an updated New Edinburgh Heritage Conservation District Plan is to provide clarity and specificity to ensure appropriate and enforceable protection for the heritage attributes of the district; THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED THAT: Under Section 8.5.1, Demolition and Relocation, reorder the guidelines so that guidelines 3 and 4 are last in this section, becoming guidelines 6 and 7, and re-number the guidelines accordingly; Under Section 8.5.2, Conservation and Maintenance, Exterior Cladding, replace subsection 2 with the following: If original cladding requires replacement it should be replaced in kind. Only deteriorated portions should be replaced. Under Section 8.5.3, 8.5.3 Additions to Existing Buildings (Contributing and Non-Contributing), General Guidelines, replace subsection 3 with the following: Additions shall normally be located in the rear yard. However, there may be instances where an addition elsewhere may be appropriate because it does not have a negative impa
pop-out
Motion To: WHEREAS the goal of adopting an updated New Edinburgh Heritage Conservation District Plan is to provide clarity and specificity to ensure appropriate and enforceable protection for the heritage attributes of the district; THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED THAT: Under Section 8.5.1, Demolition and Relocation, reorder the guidelines so that guidelines 3 and 4 are last in this section, becoming guidelines 6 and 7, and re-number the guidelines accordingly; Under Section 8.5.2, Conservation and Maintenance, Exterior Cladding, replace subsection 2 with the following: If original cladding requires replacement it should be replaced in kind. Only deteriorated portions should be replaced. Under Section 8.5.3, 8.5.3 Additions to Existing Buildings (Contributing and Non-Contributing), General Guidelines, replace subsection 3 with the following: Additions shall normally be located in the rear yard. However, there may be instances where an addition elsewhere may be appropriate because it does not have a negative impa
pop-out
B. Padolsky
L. A. (Sandy) Smallwood
M. Wilkinson
C. Quinn
C. McKenney
T. Nussbaum
S. Moffatt (a)
Motion To:
pop-out
B. Padolsky
L. A. (Sandy) Smallwood
M. Wilkinson
C. Quinn
C. McKenney
T. Nussbaum
S. Moffatt (a)

ITEM: APPLICATION TO ALTER 122 DALY AVENUE, A PROPERTY DESIGNATED UNDER PART V OF THE ONTARIO HERITAGE ACT AND LOCATED IN THE SANDY HILL WEST HERITAGE CONSERVATION DISTRICT

Motion Yes No Absent/Recused
Motion To: That the item be Carried on consent.
pop-out
B. Padolsky
L. A. (Sandy) Smallwood
M. Wilkinson
C. Quinn
C. McKenney
T. Nussbaum
S. Moffatt (a)

ITEM: APPLICATION FOR NEW CONSTRUCTION AT 600 MINTO PLACE, A PROPERTY DESIGNATED UNDER PART V OF THE ONTARIO HERITAGE ACT AND LOCATED IN THE ROCKCLIFFE PARK HERITAGE CONSERVATION DISTRICT

Motion Yes No Absent/Recused
Motion To: That the item be Carried on consent.
pop-out
L. A. (Sandy) Smallwood
M. Wilkinson
C. Quinn
C. McKenney
T. Nussbaum
S. Moffatt (a)
B. Padolsky (r)
Motion To:
pop-out
L. A. (Sandy) Smallwood
M. Wilkinson
C. Quinn
C. McKenney
T. Nussbaum
S. Moffatt (a)
B. Padolsky (a)

Public Comment Contact Information

Everyone is entitled to attend committee meetings and provide a verbal statement (up to 5 minutes long) before Councillors vote on each agenda item. If you are not able to attend a meeting, you can also email your comments to councillors. Either way, your statements become part of the official record - and this is the single most important step to shaping the outcome of your city.

Click this "mailto:" link, or cut-and-paste the following email addresses to send your comments:

catherine.mckenney@ottawa.ca, scott.moffatt@ottawa.ca, tobi.nussbaum@ottawa.ca, marianne.wilkinson@ottawa.ca

Committee Members:
Name Last Email Phone
Catherine McKenney catherine.mckenney@ottawa.ca
Scott Moffatt scott.moffatt@ottawa.ca 613-580-2491
Tobi Nussbaum tobi.nussbaum@ottawa.ca
Marianne Wilkinson marianne.wilkinson@ottawa.ca 613-580-2474